The election was a shock to an energy industry struggling to address growing investor concerns about global warming and a warning to Exxon managers that years of weak returns were no longer acceptable.
Engine No. 1 nominee Alexander Karsner, a strategist at Google owner Alphabet Inc , won the fund's third seat out of its 12-member board, according to a regulatory filing. Exxon board member and former Caterpillar (CAT.N) CEO Douglas Oberhelman also was elected, the company said.
"We look forward to working with all of our directors to build on the progress we've made to grow long-term shareholder value and succeed in a lower-carbon future," said Exxon Chief Executive Darren Woods in a statement. He was unavailable for further comment.
The activist campaign's success is part of a "tidal wave" of investor concerns on environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG) issues, said Exxon Director Ursula Burns, who spoke Wednesday evening at a Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas virtual event.
The company's response to environmental criticisms "has not been well done," Burns said, adding: "that's one of the thing we have to work on," noting its investments in carbon capture and storage technologies. Burns was one of the directors who secured a seat last week.
Woods, who campaigned against the challenger, was re-elected by 94.1%, a larger margin than a year ago. A non-binding shareholder proposal asking the company to split the CEO and chairman's roles was supported by 22.1% compared to 32.7% last year, according to preliminary numbers released on Wednesday.
Directors Steven Kandarian, Samuel Palmisano and Wan Zulkiflee will exit the 12-person board, the filing said. Former Malaysian state oil company chief Zulkiflee was appointed in February after Exxon received blunt criticism its directors lacked energy experience. Former IBM CEO Palmisano was the board's longest serving director with 15 years.
Engine No. 1 nominees Kaisa Hietala, a former executive at Finish refiner Neste Oyj (NESTE.HE), and Gregory Goff, a former top executive at Marathon Petroleum (MPC.N) and Andeavor, were the ninth and tenth largest vote recipients, respectively.
"We hope the existing board directors will work with the new non-executive directors and benefit from their significant experience with transition plans and in renewable energy," said Bess Joffe, at the Church Commissioners for England, which invests for the Church of England.
The tallies remain preliminary as the counting continues a week after Exxon's annual meeting, where the company delayed proceedings by taking a recess, a move criticized by Engine No. 1 as a pretext to continue to solicit votes.
"People who are expecting substantive changes soon at (Exxon) will likely be sorely disappointed," said Mark Stoeckle, senior portfolio manager at Adams Funds. "Repositioning XOM from a company focused on oil to one focused on climate change issues will take a long, long time."
